| Game | Date | Most Valuable Player |
| XLV | Feb. 6, 2011 | Green Bay QB Aaron Rodgers |
| XLIV | Feb. 7, 2010 | New Orleans QB Drew Brees |
| XLIII | Feb. 1, 2009 | Pittsburgh WR Santonio Holmes |
| XLII | Feb. 3, 2008 | New York Giants QB Eli Manning |
| XLI | Feb. 4, 2007 | Indianapolis QB Peyton Manning |
| XL | Feb. 5, 2006 | Pittsburgh WR Hines Ward |
| XXXIX | Feb. 6, 2005 | New England WR Deion Branch |
| XXXVIII | Feb. 1, 2004 | New England QB Tom Brady |
| XXXVII | Jan. 26, 2003 | Tampa Bay S Dexter Jackson |
| XXXVI | Feb. 3, 2002 | New England QB Tom Brady |
| XXXV | Jan. 28, 2001 | Baltimore LB Ray Lewis |
| XXXIV | Jan. 30, 2000 | St. Louis QB Kurt Warner |
| XXXIII | Jan. 31, 1999 | Denver QB John Elway |
| XXXII | Jan. 25, 1998 | Denver RB Terrell Davis |
| XXXI | Jan. 26, 1997 | Green Bay KR/PR Desmond Howard |
| XXX | Jan. 28, 1996 | Dallas CB Larry Brown |
| XXIX | Jan. 29, 1995 | San Francisco QB Steve Young |
| XXVIII | Jan. 30, 1994 | Dallas RB Emmitt Smith |
| XXVII | Jan. 31, 1993 | Dallas QB Troy Aikman |
| XXVI | Jan. 26, 1992 | Washington QB Mark Rypien |
| XXV | Jan. 27, 1991 | New York Giants RB Ottis Anderson |
| XXIV | Jan. 28, 1990 | San Francisco QB Joe Montana |
| XXIII | Jan. 22, 1989 | San Francisco WR Jerry Rice |
| XXII | Jan. 31, 1988 | Washington QB Doug Williams |
| XXI | Jan. 25, 1987 | New York Giants QB Phil Simms |
| XX | Jan. 26, 1986 | Chicago DE Richard Dent |
| XIX | Jan. 20, 1985 | San Francisco QB Joe Montana |
| XVIII | Jan. 22, 1984 | Los Angeles Raides RB Marcus Allen |
| XVII | Jan. 30, 1983 | Washington RB John Riggins |
| XVI | Jan. 24, 1982 | San Francisco QB Joe Montana |
| XV | Jan. 25, 1981 | Oakland QB Jim Plunkett |
| XIV | Jan. 20, 1980 | Pittsburgh QB Terry Bradshaw |
| XIII | Jan. 21, 1979 | Pittsburgh QB Terry Bradshaw |
| XII | Jan. 15, 1978 | Dallas DT Randy White Dallas DE Harvey Martin |
| XI | Jan. 9, 1977 | Oakland WR Fred Biletnikoff |
| X | Jan. 18, 1976 | Pittsburgh WR Lynn Swann |
| IX | Jan. 12, 1975 | Pittsburgh RB Franco Harris |
| VIII | Jan. 13, 1974 | Miami RB Larry Csonka |
| VII | Jan. 14, 1973 | Miami S Jake Scott |
| VI | Jan. 16, 1972 | Dallas QB Roger Staubach |
| V | Jan. 17, 1971 | Dallas LB Chuck Howley |
| IV | Jan. 11, 1970 | Kansas City QB Len Dawson |
| III | Jan. 12, 1969 | New York Jets QB Joe Namath |
| II | Jan. 14, 1968 | Green Bay QB Bart Starr |
| I | Jan. 15, 1967 | Green Bay QB Bart Starr |