Despite Injury, Pike's Numbers Better Than Tebow's

By JOHN P. WISE
One Great Season

WASHINGTON, Pa. -- If it were up to Cy Young voters to determine college football's Heisman Trophy winner, you'd probably see Cincinnati's Tony Pike back on the list.

If there could be such a thing as a popular darkhorse, Pike was it by midseason. He was averaging 10 touchdown passes and 4,000 yards a game it seemed, before missing three full games and parts of two others with an injured forearm. Fortunately for the Bearcats, sophomore backup Zach Collaros filled in so splendidly at quarterback that when Pike was rounding back into form, coach Brian Kelly had an embarrassment of riches at the position for still-unbeaten UC.

And while the injury gave fans in Clifton reason to be excited for next season with Collaros at the helm, the missed time cost Pike a chance to become the school's first Heisman winner.

---

WHILE YOU WERE EATING TURKEY... + GAMEDAY GALLERY: Pittsburgh at West Virginia
+ OPINION: I Hate The Cliche Holiday Piece, But ...
+ IMAGES: The Hot Girls Of College Football
+ DONATE: 30 Thousand Helpers
+ VIDEO: OGS Featured On FOX61 In Hartford
+ FOLLOW: Facebook, Twitter

---

Baseball writers gave rising superstar Tim Lincecum his second straight Cy Young Award this month, in one of the more intriguing votes in recent history. Lincecum needed only 15 wins to grab the NL honor, while AL stud Zack Greinke won just 16 games en route to becoming the Kansas City Royals' first such honoree.

Obviously, those writers recognized quality over quantity, and while Heisman voters will have a hard time ignoring Texas quarterback Colt McCoy's prolific numbers, Pike boasts the kind of consistent dominance that could possibly earn him at least a few votes if he closes with another stellar effort Saturday in a nationally televised Big East championship game against Pittsburgh. Something to tell the grandchildren.

Despite the limited action, Pike's passing numbers are actually slightly better than those of Florida's Tim Tebow, who won the Heisman in 2007.

Pike:

+ 162-for-249 passing, 2,048 yards and 23 TDs and 3 INTs.
+ Passer rating of 162.22.
+ He's had two games with 30+ completions, and four games with 300+ yards.

Tebow:

+ 162-of-244 passing, 2,166 yards, 17 TDs and 4 INTs.
+ Passer rating of 160.67
+ He hasn't completed more than 17 passes in a game this season, and hasn't thrown for more than 255 yards.

Certainly Tebow is the most dangerous running quarterback in the country, so he's got a large edge over Pike in that category. But Tebow also has one of the nation's top defenses in his own locker room. Pike's defensive mates aren't nearly as dominant, so he's had to earn his unbeaten record this year more than Tebow has earned his.

I'm not saying Pike is a better quarterback or that he deserves first-place Heisman consideration, but it would be nice for his incredible performance this season to be recognized appropriately.

Comments

[Saint]

I would love for him or Mardy to get some recognition, sadly I do not think they will.

[Dave]

By these stat, how about Colt McCoy?

+ 310 for 432 for 3328 yards; 29 TD and 10 Int
+ Passer rating of 152.9
+ Four games with 30+ completions and five games with 300+ yards.

Pike's a very good QB, but he hasn't done it against the same level of talent that Tebow and McCoy have played against.

I'm neither a UC, Florida, nor Texas fan, but I honestly think McCoy is the most deserving this year.

And no matter what Pike does, Cincinnati is new to the national stage and still isn't getting the respect across the board.

[John P. Wise]

Dave, yeah, I agree that McCoy should win it this year. I mentioned in this piece that Heisman voters won't be able to ignore McCoy's prolific numbers, but at the same time, I wouldn't necessarily say the quality of teams Tebow and McCoy have played are far superior to the competition Pike has faced. Pike is the only QB to beat 2 teams from BCS conferences -- Tebow 1, McCoy 0 -- outside of league play, including Oregon State, now ranked 13 in the AP poll.

If Pike would have stayed healthy this season and continued to put up those types of numbers, I wonder how many Heisman voters would have placed the newcomer atop their ballots.